“I’m honestly going to go home and cry,” Kathryn Swain, 53, told The Post, noting that she had gotten everything bagel with plain cream cheese and tomato from the shop every day. “It’s ...

“I’m honestly going to go home and cry,” Kathryn Swaine, 53, told The Post, noting that she had gotten an everything bagel with plain cream cheese and tomato from the shop every day.

On Dec. 30, 1984, Ken and Marguerite Ryan opened The Bagelry in a snowstorm and grossed $63. When it became apparent how many ...

Bagel Bistro's cream cheese with nova, onion, tomato. Of note, I visited on a Sunday about an hour before closing time, and the kitchen was still bringing fresh bagels out to restock the baskets.